My friends and family have asked me what I believe the best electric griddle is. They don’t always want outdoor griddles, but they still crave the experience of cooking on a griddle. I’m always happy to do some research and use my experience to make informed suggestions to help them out when choosing the best electric griddles.
There seem to be new models coming out each year, so every few months I like to read the reviews and buy one for a friend or family member. After spending quite a while looking through the top 100 electric griddles and reading countless electric griddle reviews, I’m now confident I can answer that question.
In this list you’ll find the most comprehensive review of all the best griddles currently on the market for 2023 and you can read about the complaints and features for each of them. Every electric griddle has at least one complaint and most have much more than one.
I really wanted to spend the time to look through all of the electric griddles currently on the market, mainly because I enjoy giving these as gifts since they are pretty inexpensive. In this quick electric griddle buying guide I’ll share with you what I found after spending all this time looking for the best electric griddle.
Let’s take a closer look at the best electric griddle reviews currently on the market. The first thing most people think of when they see an electric griddle is bacon and eggs. There’s so much more you can do with your electric griddle than this.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you choose to purchase through an affiliate link, we may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. You can see our full disclaimer here.
#1 Presto – 22″ Non Stick Electric Griddle (Most Popular)
The Presto 22″electric griddle is an incredibly popular electric griddle. Presto is a very good brand in my opinion, and I’m a big fan of this electric griddle, which comes in several different sizes. It has a similar non-stick surface to most of their other electric griddles.
The surface has a textured cooking diamond pattern that’s designed to disburse the heat more evenly throughout the surface of the griddle. The griddle is a lot lower than most and has only a couple of inches of clearance.
This may help to conserve more heat by not dissipating the heat with a larger gap. The other thing to note is that the entire surface is flat, not curved like many other electric griddles, so you need to be careful when cooking to make sure the food doesn’t fall off.
The price is very low compared to many other brands and it seems to perform just as well as many of the higher-priced models.
Surface Area: 231 Square Inches
- Larger surface area than many other electric griddles
- Textured non-stick surface
- Heats up to 350°
- Removable handles for storage
- Submersible surface for cleaning
Several people have complained that warping occurs in the center of the griddle after long-term usage. Some people complained that the temperature doesn’t get hot enough to toast bread. This model does have a lower maximum temperature of only 350 degrees and sometimes it may not get this hot.
The cooking surface has a tendency to heat unevenly like many electric griddles. Overall, there are far fewer negative things said about this model than some other models.
#2 Presto Tilt ‘n Drain – Extra Large Electric Griddle
After looking for the largest electric griddles, this extra-large electric griddle is a more popular option and one stands out the most. The problem with large electric griddles is that they don’t make many of them. Perhaps there isn’t a high demand, or maybe they aren’t easy to make them.
The Tilt ‘n Drain – Big Griddle, is BIG. Easily enough surface area to cook for several people and it heat up surprisingly fast.
I watched a video where they used a thermometer and a timer and it heated up to 350 degrees in a little under 10 minutes. This is the standard amount of time it takes for griddles but most electric griddles are not this large.
The thing that I like most about the large electric griddles is that you can cook plenty of perfect huge pancakes in just one session, without having to make multiple batches.
Cooking Area: 277 Square Inches
- Cooking Surface: 18.5″ X 15″
- Heats up to 400°
- Textured non-stick surface
- Submersible surface for cleaning
With thousands of reviews there were only a few people who had something bad to say. Oftentimes you will get a high percentage of people complaining about something but with this one there was only one major complaint. The heat! Surprise, this is always the biggest complaint and you’re never going to find a popular electric griddle where someone isn’t complaining about the heat.
When a griddle is this large it takes a lot of power to heat it up and even then it may not get hot enough. The other complaint is not heating evenly, which is a complaint common with about 90% of all-electric griddles.
#3 Elite Gourmet – Electric Griddle Pan with Glass Lid
In the past few years the electric griddle pans have become more and more popular. Similar to a standard electric griddle, they use a heating element and temperature controller. However the major difference is that it’s a pan and not the standard rectangular electric griddle design.
The addition of a glass lid makes the Elite Gourmet electric griddle pan unique as far as electric griddles are concerned. There are several different styles of electric griddle pans, and this one is designed for cooking meats, fish, vegetables and other grillable-style foods.
This is a very well thought out design for an electric griddle pan that I’m surprised nobody developed sooner.
The smaller design of the electric griddle pans with a glass lid means that you food will heat up much faster. The griddle easily removes and is submersible for cleaning, while the drip pan is also removable so that you can put it in the dishwasher after cooking.
It has a 14” surface and includes five adjustable heat control settings. The drip tray acts as you might think, preventing any waste of oil that drips out over the sides.
Cooking Area: 196 Square Inches
- Clear glass lid
- Heats up to 450°
- 14″ nonstick grilling surface
- 1 year replacement warranty
- Submersible, PFOA-free nonstick surface
As always, there will be complaints when it comes to electric griddles. The big one here is a complaint regarding the temperature. Several people have said that it does not heat up, while yet many others have said the opposite. It’s possible that there are some malfunctions with the heating controller on some units.
The overwhelming majority of people who have tried this electric griddle pan have loved it, so in my opinion it’s worth taking a chance on. The manufacturer does offer a one year warranty.
#4 Black & Decker
While reading all of the electric griddle reviews, the Black and Decker GD2011B stands out. It is very reasonably priced and perhaps one of the least expensive electric griddles you can buy.
This is probably why it’s so popular. This electric griddle is dishwasher safe but you shouldn’t rely too much on a dishwasher to clean your griddle.
It’s best to simply take a minute to hand wash it when you’re finished. The heat is distributed uniformly using a 500 watt healing coil that gets up to 400 degrees. The coating is a non-stick Teflon layer and they don’t really say much more than that.
Surface Area: 220 Square Inches
- Product dimensions 22”x12”, cooking surface 20”x11”, 8 servings.
- Nonstick cooking surface, Drip tray for easy clean up.
- Dishwasher safe.
- 500 Watts at 120 Volts
A big con with many electric griddles is the very short cord lengths. I used to have one that had a one foot cord length and always made me angry. The cord length on this unit is 2 feet.
The grease tray is pretty tiny and holds about a half cup of oil, which is too small if you’re going to cook very greasy foods like hamburgers or bacon. The time it takes to get to 400 degrees is about 10 minutes on average, which is a lot longer than most other electric griddles.
#5 Zojirushi – Gourmet Ceramic Electric Griddle (My Favorite!)
For Christmas this year I bought my grandfather this Zojirushi ceramic griddle.
This griddle heats up very quickly and evenly. One of my biggest problems with electric griddles is that they take forever to heat up. Some of them even make weird noises when heating up. The Zojirushi gets hot quickly and doesn’t make any of these strange noises from other lower-quality brands.
I also really like that it comes with a ceramic lid. I enjoy steaming my food and a problem with a lot of electric griddles is that they don’t come with a lid!
I really like the Zojirushi. There’s a review I was reading where somebody took a FLIR thermal imaging camera to measure the heat distribution and it was surprisingly very even.
I’m not sure why all companies don’t use this technology to measure the heat of their griddles. Probably because they know that they would find that the heat is not distributing very evenly, as well as a lower temperature than advertised.
Cooking Area: 237 Square Inches
- Keep Warm (176°F) to 425°F
- Disassemble for Easy Cleaning
- Heats up to 400°
- 19″ x 12.5″ ceramic cooking surface with nonstick coating
If you ask me, this might be the best electric griddle. Out of hundreds of reviews, only a few have complained.
Most complaints are in regard to the heating temperature not reaching its full 400 degrees. The FLIR thermal imaging showed that the maximum output temperature was 250 degrees. Most electric griddles do not seem to get up to 400 degrees and this is the average temperature. You can use the lid to heat it up quickly.
Overall, few have anything bad to say about this electric griddle other than it not heating up to the expected temperature.
#6 Hamilton Beach – 3-in-1 Countertop Electric Griddle
This Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Griddle has a very unique design. It comes with two removable cast iron griddle plates that are also reversible. It comes with two separate heating elements with control on each side that heat up to 400 degrees each. This is pretty cool because you can cook one side on a lower heat and one side at a higher heat.
The grease tray runs down the center of the unit and both the left and right sides drip into it. Overall I think that this is a really cool design that allows you to use one flat griddle and one ridged griddle for cooking meats and vegetables. The plates are not exactly non-stick, they are cast iron, so you have to be a little more careful when cooking.
Cooking Area: 180 Square Inches
- Cast iron plates are reversible – flat and ridged
- Ceramic PFOA-free cast iron cooking plates
- Heats up to 400°
- Two Removable surfaces for easy cleaning
There have been a variety of different complaints with this model, so let’s take a look at some of them.
First, the biggest complaint is the time it takes to heat up. You can expect to wait at least 10 minutes before reaching the ideal temperature.
Second, the mess it can make from only using one grease tray is big. They should have probably used two grease trays.
Finally, the last complaint is the overall design. People have complained of knobs breaking off, grease running under the heating elements, and the low heat of the heating plates.
Large Electric Griddles
People often want a large electric griddle to cook for friends and family. One of the biggest complaints I’ve heard from people after reading countless large electric griddle reviews, is that their griddle isn’t big enough for them.
Often times people like to cook for friends and family and a large electric griddle will save time. The problem with a large electric griddle is that it can take longer for them to heat up. If you’re patient then these can be a great option for parties or large gatherings.
The largest griddles for ‘regular’ cooking are generally outdoor griddles, which use propane to heat up the surface. If you want the largest griddle, then you’re not going to find that it’s electric. As the size of the electric griddle increases, so does the price.
The largest electric griddles are used in restaurants to cook food for a lot of people and can measure 1,000+ square inches cooking surface. This type of electric griddle will be out of the price range of those who only want to use their griddle to occasionally cook food for family and friends.
That’s why I have narrowed down the list to the most affordable large electric griddles I could possibly find. I wanted to go through and measure the surface area of each griddle to see which were the largest in my attempt to find the best large electric griddle.
#7 Costzon Teppanyaki-style Griddle – Largest Electric Griddle
My first impression of this one was, wow! This is the largest electric griddle I have ever seen! The Costzon electric griddle measures 35” long and has a cooking surface of 315 square inches. Almost double the size of most common electric griddles.
Another thing to point out is that it’s 2000 Watts of power, which is almost 3x more power than standard electric griddles. In theory this should mean that it heats up faster and gets hotter than most griddles. It also has a 35” long cord, which is double the length of most griddles.
Cooking Area: 315 Square Inches
- Cooking Surface: 35″ X 9″
- Heats up to 400°
- Non-stick coating surface
This might be the largest electric griddle, but many of the reviews are not kind. Complaints range from uneven heating to the griddle to inconsistent thermostat controls.
I’ve never seen a rectangular shape like this and I think it would be a huge hit at a party. This large electric griddle is pretty much designed solely for parties are large family a get together. I can’t see why you would use such a large electric griddle for cooking food on a daily basis.
#8 Broil King – ‘Professional’ Electric Griddle
The Broil King PCG-10 claims to be a professional electric griddle and has a ton of reviews. I spent almost an hour reading them all. It was interesting to find that some people had horrible experiences, while the next person loves it.
First, I’ll say that it looks a lot larger in the pictures. It has a 220 square inch cooking surface area, which is quite the standard size. The non-stick surface is made of a material called Xylan.
This is a new non-stick ceramic coating that’s supposed to be super non-stick and is certified PTFE free. It comes with a stainless steel back panel to prevent oil from splashing out and also comes with a 2 year replacement warranty. Overall, the reviews have been mainly positive. It heats up to 425 degrees and does so rather quickly. I found some good tips from a reviewer that has owned this unit for 3 years and posts a review annually with an update.
Cooking Area: 220 Square Inches
- Removable stainless-steel backsplash
- Heats up to 425°
- Cooking Surface is 20 x 11 inches
- 2 year replacement warranty
- Non-stick new surface coating with Xylan #OC483 & 8333
Not many horror stories with this electric griddle but there are still a few complaints that are worth looking into. There are some pretty gruesome photos of people having pancakes stick to the griddle surface and not un-sticking.
The electrical controller melted for one person after setting the heat to high. Complaints have also been made about the overall quality. As if the controller sparking and melting isn’t enough, the new Xylan surfaces may not be as non-stick as it claims.
Overall, the biggest complaint is the cheap controller and for the price you would expect them to include a better one. There are just too many complaints for me to recommend this one. I was actually thinking about buying this one because I liked the design but there are just too many negative things that have been said about it.
Small Electric Griddles
A small electric griddle is ideal for those that don’t want to spend much money. They are inexpensive and work very well because there isn’t as much surface area to heat up as the large electric griddles. I’ve given these as gifts before since they’re very affordable.
However, I really wanted to take a closer look at the small electric griddle reviews out there. There are several things you need to watch out for with these smaller griddles.
The usual things to watch out for are uneven heat distribution on the surface of your electric griddle. We found a few griddles that heat up really quickly and stay hot.
You also want it to be easy to clean and easy to store. This is what makes these smaller griddles so cool. You can store them easily in a cabinet, whereas the large electric griddles can be a bit cumbersome and hard to store.
The last thing we consider Is just how small do you want your electric griddle to be? There is a point where it just may be unreasonably small and you can only cook one pancake at a time.
#9 Presto Liddle Griddle – Best Small Electric Griddle
While looking through hundreds of small electric griddle reviews there is one that stands out the most, and that’s the Liddle Griddle by Presto.
This one has the smallest cooking area of all the electric griddles on the list. The good thing about having such a small surface area is that this griddle heats up fast and gets really hot. This style of griddle is ideal for one person and perfect for cooking eggs, steaks, hamburgers, sandwiches and much more.
The temperature was tested with a thermometer and reached a surprising 390 degrees. The entire surface heated evenly, which is unheard of as far as electric griddles go. The reason why most larger electric griddle can’t maintain even heat is because there is just too much surface area.
A good heating element, controller and surface plate are not cheap, so if you want an electric griddle like this one but twice as large you’re going to be looking at spending a lot more.
Cooking Area: 90 Square Inches
- Ideal for one or two people
- Can fit 2 eggs and 2 pieces of toast
- Heats up to 400 degrees quickly
- Surface is non-stick cast aluminum
- Built-in grease tray
Finally, an electric griddle without all the complaints about heating unevenly! Since the Liddle Griddle is so small, it heats up perfectly even. Complaints regarding this griddle were regarding the light indicator, which doesn’t tell you if it’s hot or cold. So be careful and unplug it and put it out of reach of children to cool down when you’re done.
The grease collector is usually another complaint for more electric griddles but no so with this one. The grease collector is not removable, so you don’t have to slide it out to clean it.
Other than that this certainly is the best small electric griddle.
#10 Nesco – 8” Small Electric Griddle / Skillet
I’m a big fan of a griddle that has a lid, especially a glass lid. These are very hard to come by, so when I do find one like this little Nesco with a glass lid I take the time to look at all the reviews.
Nesco is a brand I’m familiar with, as they seem to specialize in making skillets and big electric roaster pans.
This little griddle is actually a skillet, but I love that it’s one piece and is very sturdy. It’s perfect for one or two people and has a deeper wall than most griddles (which is why it really falls into the skillet family).
The great thing about these small electric griddles is that they heat up super fast. This one heats up the quickest due to the glass lid. Overall, this is a great electric skillet / griddle and can be used to cook a great many varieties of food.
Cooking Area: 64 Square Inches
- Temperature range to 400°F
- Surface is 8” x 8” with a 1.75” depth.
- The surface is flat non-stick aluminum coating
Like most electric griddles, you’ll find complaints about the heat controller. You’d think they would have mastered this by now but on just about every griddle I can find there’s always someone complaining that the controller doesn’t work.
Other than this, it can get very hot on the bottom of the griddle and one person said it burned their countertop.
#11 Morning Star – Crepe Maker Pro – 13” Electric Griddle Pan
The electric griddle pan has been very popular in Europe for its ease of use in making crepes. There are however many more uses than just making crepes. This Morning Star electric griddle design has a flat round griddle made from high quality non-stick aluminum. It’s ideal for cooking hamburgers, bacon, pancakes, vegetables and of course, crepes.
The Crepe maker pro has such good reviews that I had to add it to this list. Although it doesn’t call itself an electric griddle pan, that’s essentially what it is. The griddle surface heats up to 400 degrees and the smaller surface area makes it faster to cook your food. It is ideal for making large pancakes and crepes as well as just about anything else you can think up.
Cooking Area: 133 Square Inches
- Cook pancakes, tortillas, eggs, bacon, sausage, omelets, flat breads, and more!
- Heats up to 400°
- 13″ aluminum non-stick plate
- 1 year replacement warranty
- Non-stick surface
- 1000W heats the cooking surface quickly
Hundreds of reviews and not too many complaints. Some said that the quality is cheaply made. Now that this product has been out for a while, other reviews are rolling in that mention the durability isn’t what they would expect.
The other negative thing I found is that it doesn’t include a scraper.
Overall, this is certainly one of the prettiest electric griddle pans currently on the market and can be used for a lot more than making crepes.
Hopefully you’ve found what you were looking for in this review of the best electric griddles. We really looked at all the top griddles on the market to bring you this list. I wanted to make sure that I only picked out the top griddles in the best categories I could.
Over the past decade there have been many improvements to the electric griddle. When I was a little girl, we had to wait forever for our griddle to heat up and the surface was so small you could only cook a few pancakes at a time. You should think of your electric griddle as the biggest pan in your house. In restaurants, they usually use steel griddles to cook the food. The quality of your electric griddle will have a direct impact on the taste of your food.
The great thing about electric griddles is their simplistic design, which results in good life expectancy and easy maintenance. Since they rely on electricity rather than gas, the cost of operating an electric griddle is often cheaper than using natural gas or propane as your cooking source.
Once you’ve made your choice of the best electric griddle for your needs, make use of it and enjoy your griddle cooking!